Ultimate Survivor Tribal Council Bracket – Historic Division Round Three

Well, that last round was chalk picks all the way for the historic bracket. I guess Andy did a good job at seeding or something. Now the final four must face off to see who makes it to the sweet sixteen. Will it still be the favorites, or will there be a (mild) upset? My money is on the top seeds, but your vote will decide it.

PRTribalBracket_Historic_v1
Click to see full size graphic.

Voting criteria:

  • You decide what makes a Tribal worthy of your vote. Was it your favourite? The best? Most memorable? Most dramatic? It’s up to you. We’ve organized them by theme, but you’re under no obligation to pick the most historic tribal to represent the Historical bracket.
  • Tribal Council is defined as everything that happened in episode from when the tribe gets to Tribal Council through to the Final Words of the eliminated contestant. Things that didn’t make the air were out of bounds for consideration when putting the list together.
  • For Final Tribal Councils, the reveal of the winner is out of bounds (except for the first Final Tribal). This takes place at a different time and place and is aired on a different episode.

Voting ends on Tuesday, March 29th.

1. Snakes and Rats vs 4. The Purple Rock

survivor-borneo-tribal-council-sue-hawk-snakes-and-rats 

1. Snakes and Rats – Borneo, episode 13 “The Final Four” vs 4. The Purple Rock – Marquesas, episode 13 “The Soul Survivor”

Ohhhhhhhhhhhh snap. One of the favorites to win the whole tournament versus our namesake? This is going to be a tough one. Or maybe not. The “Snakes and Rats” speech is not just one of the most seminal moments in Survivor history, but one of the most important and well-known moments in reality television as a genre. The first rock draw was a shocking moment and changed both the rules and gameplay of Survivor, but Sue’s speech changed god damn television. And that’s if we’re just considering one moment of that tribal council. I would be remiss to not mention Greg’s “pick a number” jury question, leading to the only memorable Kelly Wiglesworth moment in Survivor: Cambodia. Then of course, there’s that fact that this is the only tribal council with a winner announcement, which means it includes Richard Hatch winning the game with strategy, thus allowing the very show we love to still exist 31 seasons later.

But the Marquesas final four tribal did inspire the name of a pretty amazing podcast…

Read more about Sue’s speech in our 30 from 30 series.

Read more about the first rock draw in our 30 from 30 series.

1. Snakes and Rats vs 4. The Purple Rock

  • 1. Snakes and Rats (75% Votes)
  • 4. The Purple Rock (25% Votes)

Total Voters: 387

Loading ... Loading ...

2. No Votes Count vs 3. Kelley Wentworth Negates 9 Votes

 

2. No Votes Count – Cambodia, episode 14 “Lie, Cheat and Steal” vs 3. Kelley Wentworth Negates 9 Votes – Cambodia, episode 8 “You Call, We Haul”

Wentworth idol versus Wentworth (and Jeremy) idol. Record-breaking tribal council versus record breaking tribal council. Although even Savage would admit that more pleasure is taken watching him leave the game than Kimmi, that doesn’t mean his boot is going to run away with it.

There can be no accusations of recency bias for this matchup, even if I personally think the most recent moment should be the one to move forward. Because look, Kelley playing her idol and negating nine votes (the most ever!) was awesome. Basically, she’s a bad ass. But that final six… we may never see anything like that again. Two idols played, no votes count, and the dominant alliance manages to weed out their turncoat. An attempted blindside mixed with strategy and theatrics to make a historic tribal council. No votes count. It’s what inspired the creation of this bracket in the first place.

2. No Votes Count vs 3. Kelley Wentworth Negates 9 Votes

  • 2. No Votes Count (69% Votes)
  • 3. Kelley Wentworth Negates 9 Votes (31% Votes)

Total Voters: 406

Loading ... Loading ...

The Rest of the Bracket

PRTribalBracket_v3
Click to see the full-size graphic.

Blindsides Bracket

Strategic Bracket

Theatrics Bracket

Emma
Follow me

Emma

Emma is the token chick of the Purple Rock Podcast. She has watched the show continuously since the second episode and is pretty sure she's never seen the pilot.

Favorite seasons: Heroes vs. Villains, Micronesia, Cambodia, Cook Islands, China, Philippines

Favorite players: Courtney Yates, Parvati Shallow, John Cochran, Cirie Fields, Yul Kwon, Kim Spradlin
Emma
Follow me
  • Mike Hirsch

    No votes count, sure, it’s momentous. It’s historic. But I have to vote with Wentworth negating 9 votes. Because that was flat out fantastic. And also because of all the blurred middle fingers.

    • I’m right there with you. Besides that….no votes count became a thing because Spencer screwed up. He went out of his way to comfort Kelley and tell her that it’s not her, which immediately caused the chain reaction of both Kelley and Jeremy playing their idols. Had Spencer let it ride, he could have potentially voted out Jeremy at F6 and come after Kelley at F5. I also worry that the whole “historic thing happening at Tribal Council” hype ruined that Tribal for me. Wentworth playing her idol is the epitome of a smart move. She not only played her idol correctly, but she also got rid of the person who was most likely not to work with her and her alliance mates. Yes, she should have gotten rid of Jeremy, but had she done that, she just would have went out in Wiglesworth’s spot.

  • Max_Jets

    No votes count is entertaining for all the reactions, but falls a bit flat for me because it doesn’t work from a game play perspective. Nobody has any incentive to switch their vote (except Keith), which makes it a pretty shitty tiebreaker in the same way the purple rock of Marquesas was. Blood vs. Water F6 is still the best tie vote and it isn’t even close.

  • Roswulf

    I’m with “no votes count” all the way. No question, Wentworth’s first idol play is a beautiful moment in the story of Wentworth and Savage. But “No votes count” features three players- Kimmi, Wentworth, and Jeremy- any of whom could have plausibly won at Final Tribal- simultaneously throwing their last, best punch. And because of it’s extened structure, it managed to pack an entire storyline of betrayal-anger-revenge into a single tribal.

    And then it ended with Keith Nale, puzzling his way through a truly bizarre set of strategic circumstances. A set of circumstances where there was a “right” choice- but given it was Keith Nale, their was no certainty that he wouldn’t make a Woo-like decision to go with his heart and take the bullet.

    Oh, and Snakes and Rats. Duh.

    • Other Scott

      I don’t think it’s a Woo like decision at all.

      Woo just didn’t know how Survivor juries worked, he thought he’d win over a backstabber like Tony. Keith just didn’t want Kimmi to leave the game because she’s a mom and needed the money more, so he thought he’d take the bullet.

  • Side Character

    I don’t want vote for just one in each matchup. I love them all too much–if I choose one, I will regret it and then choose the other. It’s like Sophie’s Choice with 4 kids and I want to keep all of them. Auugghhhh! Why is this bracket so good?