Ultimate Survivor Tribal Council Bracket – Strategic Division Round Two

Now that you’ve had a week to get your strategies strategized and your alliances aligned… everybody drop your buffs. We’re switching things up. The votes have been tallied, and the next round of our Strategic bracket is upon is. Keep reading to see who survived to see another week, and who came up short in their trickery…

Click to see full size graphic.

Voting criteria:

  • You decide what makes a Tribal worthy of your vote. Was it your favourite? The best? Most memorable? Most dramatic? It’s up to you. We’ve organized them by theme, but you’re under no obligation to pick the most strategic tribal to represent the Strategic bracket.
  • Tribal Council is defined as everything that happened in episode from when the tribe gets to Tribal Council through to the Final Words of the eliminated contestant. Things that didn’t make the air were out of bounds for consideration when putting the list together.
  • For Final Tribal Councils, the reveal of the winner is out of bounds (except for the first Final Tribal). This takes place at a different time and place and is aired on a different episode.

Voting ends on Tuesday, March 22nd.

1. Parvati’s Double Idol Play vs 8. Russell Idols Out a Kelly

survivor_hvv_tribalcouncil_parvartidoubleidol-1

Parvati’s Double Idol Play – Heroes vs. Villains, episode 10 “Going Down in Flames”

Looks like an idol saved this Tribal for the next round, and deservedly so. Everyone’s fan fave JT was no match for one of the most iconic hidden immunity idol plays in Survivor history. Parvati saved her “debaucherous little villains” after a lot of cross-talk and some sneaky idol swapping that led to her having two idols—enough to protect Sandra and the real target, Jerri, in order to knock the Heroes down a peg.

Read more about this moment in our 30 from 30 series.

survivor-samoa-tribal-council-russell-plays-his-idol

Russell Idols Out a Kelly – Samoa, episode 9 “Tastes Like Chicken”

Never bet against Russel Hantz having an idol—well, except for the above tribal’s turn of events. His attempt at turning around his tribe’s Samoa fortunes beat out Jenn Brown’s ultimately-failed attempt at doing the same. Savage! But will this little troll bridge the gap to the next round? Or will he fall victim like so many men have to Parvati’s charm? Your vote may be the only thing standing in the way. (We promise the game isn’t rigged).

1. Parvati's double idol play vs. 8. Russell idols out a Kelly

  • 1. Parvati's double idol play (89% Votes)
  • 8. Russell idols out a Kelly (11% Votes)

Total Voters: 299

Loading ... Loading ...

4. Going to Rocks vs 5. Stick to the Plan

survivor-bloodvswater-tribal-council-rock-draw

Going to Rocks – Blood vs. Water, episode 12 “Rustle Feathers”

If a rock draw didn’t win this match-up, I’d be really disappointed in our readers. Only the second tie-breaker rock draw in Survivor history, this epic Tribal from Blood vs. Water drew the lucky colored rock and gets to stay in the game one more round. (Sorry, Penner).

survivor-sanjuandelsur-tribal-council-stick-to-the-plan

Stick to the Plan – San Juan del Sur, episode 10 “This is Where We Build Trust”

I was tempted to consult a thesaurus and use a bunch of words that Keith probably doesn’t understand, but instead I’ll just stick to the plan. One of the least strategic plays in this bracket, Keith Nale made up for it with his iconic phrasing that turned the middle phase of the game around (for better or worse) and gave us some smooth gameplay by Natalie that sowed the seeds of her victory path.

4. Going to rocks vs. 5. Stick to the plan

  • 4. Going to rocks (73% Votes)
  • 5. Stick to the plan (27% Votes)

Total Voters: 302

Loading ... Loading ...

2. The Three Amigos vs 10. Jeremy Saves Stephen

survivor-caramoan-tribal-council-three-amigos

The Three Amigos – Caramoan, episode 10 “Zipping Over the Cuckoo’s Nest”

You think Steve Martin and Chevy Chase ever had to worry about hidden idols? Malcolm’s bold move in Caramoan beat out Mike’s bluff from Worlds Apart, which proves that when you’re fighting from the bottom, walk the idol walk. Or else you’ll be walking down to the confessional booth. (Which, coincidentally, most of the Three Amigos did in the coming days). Can everyone’s favorite non-Joe-or-Spencer player bluff his way into the next round?

survivor_cambodia_tribal_jeremystephen-2

Jeremy Saves Stephen – Worlds Apart, episode 10 “Like Selling Your Soul to the Devil”

If anything, Malcolm’s best moment in Caramoan was “hold up, bro“. Which is why it’s complete recency bias BS that Jeremy’s idol play for Stephen last fall beat the former out last round. But something, something democracy respect the votes blah blah… Either way, Jeremy’s shocking-yet-ultimately-fruitless loyalty play survived for another vote.

2. The Three Amigos vs. 10. Jeremy saves Stephen

  • 2. The Three Amigos (63% Votes)
  • 10. Jeremy saves Stephen (37% Votes)

Total Voters: 297

Loading ... Loading ...

3. Cagayan’s Chaotic Merge vs 11. Cirie’s 3-2-1

survivor-cagayan-tribal-council-sarah-lacina-blindside

Cagayan’s Chaotic Merge – Cagayan, episode 6 “Head of the Snake”

Kass may have had a zero percent chance of winning Cagayan according to Spencer, but this Tribal had a whopping 88% chance of winning its seed last round. One of the biggest moments in a season full of them, can the merge vote continue to cause Chaos in future rounds? Or will it need a swing vote to turn things around? I’ll be hiding in the Spy Shack trying to find out.

survivor-panama-tribal-council-ciries-3-2-1

Cirie’s 3-2-1 – Panama, episode 12 “Perilous Scramble”

China‘s Final Tribal flopped harder than Amanda Kimmel last round, and the leaf-fearing strategist prevailed. Cirie’s final six numbers game counted its way to the top, and didn’t even need any help from Shane this time. Here’s to seeing if she can wrangle a plurality of your votes this time…

3. Cagayan's chaotic merge vs. 11. Cirie's 3-2-1

  • 3. Cagayan's chaotic merge (57% Votes)
  • 11. Cirie's 3-2-1 (43% Votes)

Total Voters: 292

Loading ... Loading ...

The Rest of the Bracket

PRTribalBracket_v1
Click to see the full-size graphic.

Blindsides Bracket

Theatrics Bracket

Historic Bracket

Mark
Follow me

Mark

A Survivor fan since the end of season one, Mark hasn’t finished One World, but still thinks Kim is overhyped.

Top 5, Baby: Cambodia, Cagayan, Heroes vs. Villains, Pearl Islands, and Palau.
Mark
Follow me
  • I threw a vote at Stick to the Plan because…it’s Keith. I know it won’t win, but for me, I had to support my Keith.

    • Hornacek

      Keith: (spits)

    • Hornacek

      Keith: (spits)

    • Other Scott

      Me too! But maybe more because I had to support the relief I felt at not losing Jon Misch.

      • I said on Reddit how the Alec vote is when Natalie took control of the game, but I think it is actually here.

        • Other Scott

          I think you might be right. If this goes through, Reed seizes control and has lackeys like Alec, Wes, and Keith. It’s a real uphill battle through that for Nat.

          I mean, you can make the argument that Jon still had control, but as much as I like him, he was a little too oblivious to the fact he was the obvious threat to really do the maintenance to keep himself there.

          • Yeah, Jon looked like he had control but in reality, Natalie was just biding her time to get Jon off.

          • PHRASING!

          • andythesaint

            Beat me to it.

          • Wow…not only is that bad phrasing, but it is not even the correct terminology. Good job, me!

  • Purple Rock Emma

    “Or else you’ll be walking down to the confessional booth. (Which,
    coincidentally, most of the Three Amigos did in the coming days).”
    I don’t know if that was really a coincidence. Interesting, it looks like that match up is between two flashy but ultimately fruitless moves. But Three Amigos is flashier.

    • Mike Hirsch

      Yeah, in the battle of big moves that barely mattered, definitely gotta go with Three Amigos (and, maybe that one did matter a little bit, because Eddie managed to eek fourth place out of it. Sweet, stupid Eddie).

  • Other Scott

    I’m really not seeing the appeal of the 3-2-1. Great strategic move, but the actual tribal council itself had almost nothing going on, right?

    • Side Character

      Yeah, the tribal council itself wasn’t all too memorable, although Shane’s reaction to the vote reading was for me (when I see his face I think, “Aroo?”). But I can’t recall anything of the tribal with Russell’s idol play besides him playing it and the Galu’s reaction to that. There wasn’t much else going on there either. I mostly picked the tribal councils that deployed my favourite of the strategies. Parvati’s double idol play beats Russell’s idol play any day for me (to say nothing about what happened before the idol plays).

      I picked the 3-2-1 because I think it is a more memorable strategic move–and also I love Cirie. Having her mastermind that play really showed how far she had come. I don’t mind if one or the other makes it through, though.

  • I almost voted for ‘stick to the plan’ in defiance of being told what to do. Don’t sway me. >:(