Survivor Edge of Extinction Week 2 Predictions

Now that we’re paying attention to the season again, it’s time to start predicting who will not get voted out of the game (unless they choose to be!). We skipped week one, but I almost want to give everyone points for Reem anyway.

Last Season

Before we get to it, I guess I should probably let you know how last season went. I think I might have mentioned it on the podcast, but I never posted it here. Maybe it’s because y’all won. Congrats.

Andy Brad Emma John
Mark Matt
19th place Lyrsa Carl Nick Nick Nick Jessica Nick
18th place Natalie Natalie Natalie Dan Natalie Kara Natalie
17th place Gabby Bi Bi Bi Bi Bi Bi
15th place Natalie Natalie Natalie Natalie Natalie Natalie
14th place Angelina Angelina Angelina Lyrsa Angelina Lyrsa Angelina
13th place Angelina Alec Angelina Alec Alec Carl Alec
12th place Angelina Dan Angelina Carl Carl Angelina Dan
11th place Dan Dan Dan Dan Mike Dan Dan
10th place Angelina Angelina Angelina Mike Kara Alison Angelina
9th place Alec Alison Alec Alec Carl Alec Carl
8th place Kara Alison Nick Davie Davie Davie Davie
7th place Alison Christian Alison Christian Alison Alison Alison
6th place Davie Davie Davie Alison Alison Davie Davie
5th place Alison Alison Nick Nick Davie Alison Alison
4th place Nick Mike Alison Davie Kara Nick Kara
3rd place Angelina Angelina Angelina Angelina Angelina Angelina Angelina
2nd place Mike Kara Mike Mike Mike Mike Mike
Winner Kara Nick Kara Kara Nick Kara Nick

Swept the finale, way to go readers. No one was rooting as hard for Nick as y’all.

Alright, time to bury the past.

Staff Predictions


Not a whole lot to go on with just a 60-minute premiere, so instead I’ll just go with my unmatched brilliance and experience to guess Wendy and Aubry. If you have no other reason to go with your picks, just trust that I am the smartest one here.


Who’d I say on the podcast? Aubry and Wendy right? You want my reasoning go to the podcast. Or read Andy’s reasoning since he said the same two.


Early in the season is as good as a time as any to zag with my predictions. So for Blue tribe (aka the tribe that will lose immunity), Wendy is clearly lowest on the totem pole, but this will benefit her because no one will take her seriously. Keith will not have done enough to work his way in with the rest of the tribe, and his swimming will cost them the challenge. Dissatisfied (they will never be satisfied…) with two losses out of the gate, Keith heads to the Edge of Extinction.

For the yellow tribe (aka the tribe that wins immunity), my guess doesn’t matter because, as mentioned, they will immunity. So let’s say Ron Clark gets too cute by half with his menu and sends himself home.


Manu (Mana? Blue tribe, whatever) – Wendy. Do I need to explain why? We know why.

Kama: I guess Aubry because Eric suggested it and we also barely know anyone else on that tribe and the other real option is Ron Clark, and he’ll probably have an idol if they actually go to tribal.


The preview wants me to believe Kelley is a good target. And I definitely believe David would vote out Kelley soon, because a “vote out the strong players” strategy doesn’t exactly work against him. But this week, I choose to believe instead in Survivor‘s long track record: Wendy goes home.

Joe’s tribe will not lose.


Blue tribe: I think Keith is in trouble here. His swimming will be a liability in challenges, and his willingness to go between groups could be seen as shady. Wendy is alone now and could be absorbed into another alliance (though I still don’t think she’ll last long…). I doubt the anti-Kelley wing will be able to mobilize without Wentworth and David pulling some shenanigans this early.

Yellow tribe: Yeah right, like they’ll lose immunity! Ha.

Huh? I have to pick someone? How about that lady who complained about being outside… What’s her name? Julie? Sure, her.

Andy Brad Emma John
Mark Matt
Kama 2nd Boot Aubry Ron Clark Aubry Julie Aubry
Manu 2nd Boot Wendy Keith Wendy Wendy Keith Wendy

Your Turn

Time to vote for the next person to probably not leave the show.

Who will Kama vote out of their tribe?

  • Aubry (39% Votes)
  • Julie (29% Votes)
  • Ron Clark (10% Votes)
  • Victoria (9% Votes)
  • Aurora (4% Votes)
  • Eric (4% Votes)
  • Julia (4% Votes)
  • Joe (1% Votes)
  • Gavin (0% Votes)

Total Voters: 70

Loading ... Loading ...

Who will Manu vote out of their tribe?

  • Wendy (56% Votes)
  • Keith (25% Votes)
  • Lauren (9% Votes)
  • Kelley (8% Votes)
  • Rick (1% Votes)
  • Wardog (1% Votes)
  • Chris (0% Votes)
  • David (0% Votes)

Total Voters: 80

Loading ... Loading ...